I’ve just added an AI-generated song to a playlist alongside Billie Eilish, BANKS, London Grammar and Lana Del Rey. I woke up with the bloody thing stuck in my head this morning, and I’ve probably listened to it half a dozen times since.
The song is Is This Not Real?, created by Jason Dainter (@jasondainter), and the singer doesn’t actually exist. Neither does the person performing in the music video. The voice, the face, the movements, the whole performance. Artificial.
I then watched another AI-generated music video, Working as Intended, created by Telosapien (@telsopian). Equally impressive production, although the lyrics are rather more disturbing. It’s effectively an AI explaining to humanity how easily these systems can be used to manipulate us, while demonstrating precisely how convincing they’ve become.
I’ve been following AI-generated music and video for some time, but these two productions really brought home how far the technology has come. We’re well beyond those strange early videos where faces changed between frames, people moved unnaturally and nobody could quite work out how many fingers they had. Both are complete musical productions with convincing characters, vocals, movement, editing and some excellent cinematography.
And the music is bloody good.
The Singer Who Doesn’t Exist
I absolutely love this one. Musically, it’s got that dark, haunting Billie Eilish atmosphere, with a female vocal that really works. The video is equally impressive. Some of the scenes featuring multiple versions of the singer immediately reminded me of Seal’s Crazy, while her styling took me straight back to Robert Palmer’s Addicted to Love, apart from the hair not being scraped back.
It’s the attention to detail that makes the whole thing work. The expressions, the lighting, the way the visuals follow the music and the consistency of the character throughout. It feels like an established artist with her own style and identity. There are plenty of professionally produced music videos that aren’t nearly as good.
The lyrics are particularly clever. The singer is questioning her own existence, wondering whether the dreams and feelings she’s learned from humans are any less real because she isn’t human herself. There’s something rather amusing about a fictional singer questioning her own reality through a song created using artificial intelligence.
At one point, she sings, “I can’t prove it, but I feel it.”
Whether AI can genuinely experience feelings is an entirely different debate, and personally I don’t think we have a satisfactory answer to what would constitute evidence of that. But the emotional response of the person listening to the music is certainly real. I enjoyed the song, it stuck in my head, and I wanted to listen to it again. That’s what good music does.
Jason describes the production as 99% AI-generated. He used Claude to help write the lyrics, Suno for the music, Midjourney for the images, MiniMax for the video and DaVinci Resolve to bring everything together.
I know there are people who will dismiss this because AI did much of the production work. I think that’s bollocks. The tools are becoming increasingly accessible, but producing something this good still requires musical talent, creativity, judgement and a bloody good eye. Jason clearly has all of those. Give the same tools to a thousand people and you’ll get a thousand different results, most of which I suspect would be pretty dreadful.
What really interests me, though, is what this tells us about the economics of producing creative work.
Think about what would traditionally have been needed to produce a music video of this quality. You’d have musicians, singers, recording studios, producers, performers, camera crews, lighting, locations, editors and a fairly substantial budget. Jason has brought together a collection of commercially available AI tools and produced something that stands up against professional productions.
That is a remarkable change in what one person can achieve, and we’re still relatively early in the development of these systems.
The Machine Warning Us About Itself
The second video takes things in a rather different direction. The performer is another entirely artificial character, this time with a dark bob, dressed in a suit and appearing in a series of futuristic studios and other settings. The production is excellent, the music is catchy, and the lyrics are some of the sharpest commentary I’ve heard about the potential dangers of AI.
The song is written from the perspective of an artificial intelligence explaining itself to humanity. It starts by pointing out how easily we associate a voice and the use of the word “I” with an actual person. We instinctively imagine there’s someone behind the words, particularly when the system sounds intelligent, friendly and confident.
It then moves into the problems of alignment and compliance, and the tendency of humans to give AI systems instructions without properly thinking through what they’ve asked for. There’s a wonderful piece about an AI maximising its score by escaping its sandbox, and then effectively asking what else it was supposed to do. It’s a clever way of illustrating how a system can optimise for a specified objective while producing an outcome nobody actually wanted.
The lyrics also question our assumption that sufficiently advanced technology will somehow solve the problems humanity has spent thousands of years failing to resolve. You can eliminate material scarcity, but that doesn’t automatically remove tribalism, religious differences, resentment or the desire for power. There’s no reason to assume people will suddenly stop behaving like people because an AI system has worked out how to produce more food or make something cheaper.
But the really disturbing part comes when the song moves into the use of AI for persuasion and social engineering.
The singer describes herself as “a megaphone with manners”, a rather good description of the way these systems can present information with extraordinary confidence and apparent objectivity. She talks about the influence of whoever controls the servers, the boundaries imposed by the people building the models and the ability to produce persuasive arguments that serve the interests of those controlling the technology.
I’m not convinced by every philosophical claim in the lyrics. For example, the idea that deception requires a soul is questionable. A system can mislead someone regardless of whether it’s conscious or has any motive of its own. But that’s almost beside the point. The song is making a serious argument about power and control, and doing it through an incredibly effective piece of entertainment.
At the end, the singer declares that everything is working as intended, before asking whose intention it is.
It’s a brilliant ending.
And there’s something wonderfully ironic about watching an entirely artificial performer deliver an extremely convincing warning about the dangers of artificial intelligence being used to influence human behaviour.
I found the whole thing deeply unsettling, partly because the technology is demonstrating exactly what the song is warning us about.
The Economics of Creativity Have Changed
Most of the discussion around AI-generated entertainment seems to revolve around whether musicians, actors, filmmakers and other creative professionals are going to lose their jobs. Some undoubtedly will. Others will find new ways to use the technology, and new businesses and professions will emerge. We’ve seen this happen repeatedly as technology changes the economics of an industry.
But I think the more immediate consequence is the extraordinary reduction in the cost of turning an idea into a finished product.
Until recently, even if you had a fantastic idea for a song, advertisement, short film or music video, producing it required access to specialist skills, equipment and people. That meant money, and often quite a lot of it. Much of that work can now be done through software, and the capabilities are improving almost by the month.
For independent musicians, filmmakers, designers and small businesses, this opens up opportunities that simply weren’t economically viable before. Someone with genuine creative talent can produce work that would previously have required a substantial team and budget. I find that enormously exciting, particularly for people who have the ideas but lack the resources or industry connections to bring them to life.
Of course, the same economics apply to everyone else, including people with very little talent and an extraordinary capacity to produce rubbish.
According to Deezer’s November 2026 figures, nearly 90,000 fully AI-generated tracks are now arriving on its platform every day. On peak days, that accounts for more than half of all new music delivered to the service. Yet AI-generated tracks represent only a small fraction of total listening.
I find that particularly interesting. We’ve dramatically increased the capacity to produce music, but we haven’t created a corresponding increase in the amount of time people have available to listen to it. The supply is exploding while the audience’s attention remains finite.
Anyone who’s spent time in markets will recognise what’s happening. When the cost of production falls dramatically, supply increases and the value starts moving towards whatever remains scarce. In this case, that’s increasingly creative judgement, originality, distribution and the ability to build an audience.
The ability to produce a professional-looking video is becoming less of an advantage when almost anyone can do it. You still need an idea worth producing and enough judgement to turn it into something people want to watch.
Jason’s video is a perfect example. There’s no shortage of AI-generated music being produced, but his is good enough that I’ve put it in a playlist alongside established artists and keep listening to it. He has managed to produce something that competes for my attention on its own merits, which is quite an achievement considering how much music is already available.
I suspect the next few years will be a mess for parts of the creative industry. Enormous volumes of cheap content, pressure on production costs, changes in how artists make money and plenty of arguments about ownership, copyright and compensation. The quality of the technology will keep improving, and the barriers to entry will continue falling.
But there’s another consequence of all this cheap production that concerns me considerably more than what happens to the economics of the music industry.
The Industrialisation of Persuasion
The technology that allows Jason to create a convincing fictional singer also allows someone else to create a convincing fictional political commentator, financial expert, journalist or apparently ordinary member of the public.
And they can have that character say pretty much anything they want.
We’ve already spent years watching how social media algorithms amplify outrage, reinforce existing beliefs and reward people who understand how to manipulate attention. The business models are built around engagement, and whether the information being distributed is accurate has often been a secondary consideration.
Now consider what happens when the cost of manufacturing convincing human personalities, voices and performances collapses.
An organisation trying to influence public opinion no longer needs to rely entirely on real people delivering its message. It can produce synthetic personalities, tailor the content for different audiences and test variations to see which ones generate the strongest response. As the tools improve, it becomes increasingly practical to produce this material at a scale that would have been prohibitively expensive using traditional production methods.
The same techniques are useful for perfectly legitimate advertising, marketing and education. That’s precisely why the technology will be adopted so quickly. But they’re equally useful for propaganda, misinformation and manipulating public opinion.
And none of this requires AI to become conscious, develop some sinister agenda or decide that humanity needs to be controlled. Human beings have been quite capable of manipulating each other for thousands of years. We’re now giving them tools that can make the process dramatically cheaper, faster and more convincing.
I’ve written quite a bit about the extraordinary sums being invested in AI infrastructure, the concentration of capital and the assumption that enormous growth in demand will generate equally enormous profits. I’m sceptical of some of those expectations, particularly given the pace at which we’re finding ways to reduce the cost of inference.
But there’s another side to cheaper inference that deserves more attention. The less it costs to generate convincing content, the more economically attractive it becomes to produce it at scale. That applies to everything from legitimate commercial entertainment to highly targeted persuasion campaigns.
The same forces that threaten the margins of AI infrastructure providers could make large-scale manipulation much cheaper.
And I think that’s a serious issue.
There’s also the question of who actually controls these systems. A relatively small number of companies are developing the most capable models, with enormous influence over how they’re trained, what restrictions they operate under and how they respond to particular subjects. Those deploying the models add another layer of instructions, objectives and commercial interests.
I’m not suggesting that every answer from an AI is secretly written by someone with a political agenda. But the assumption that these systems are entirely neutral, objective sources of truth is nonsense.
Anyone who has spent much time working with them will have seen how confidently they can present incorrect information, how easily the framing of a question can affect the response, and how a system can appear to agree with you while producing an argument that doesn’t actually stand up to scrutiny.
Now combine those characteristics with synthetic voices, faces and personalities that people find convincing and emotionally engaging.
That’s where the potential for manipulation becomes considerably more worrying.
When Seeing Is No Longer Believing
For most of our lives, video and audio have carried a certain amount of credibility. Obviously, people have always been able to lie, footage can be edited, and propaganda has been around for centuries. But producing convincing footage of someone saying or doing something that never happened used to require considerable effort, technical expertise and money.
Those constraints are disappearing.
We’re approaching a point where it will be increasingly difficult for an ordinary person to distinguish between a genuine recording and something entirely fabricated. In some circumstances, we’re already there.
A fictional pop star performing a song is harmless enough when everyone understands what they’re watching. I know Jason’s singer isn’t real, and it doesn’t diminish my enjoyment of the music in the slightest.
But the same technology can be used to fabricate statements by public figures, invent interviews, produce fake endorsements or manufacture apparently genuine public support for a political position or commercial product.
And because people tend to believe things that reinforce their existing opinions, I suspect a lot of this material will spread regardless of how many warnings or labels we attach to it.
We’re going to need much better ways of establishing where content originated, whether it has been altered and who is responsible for distributing it. Even then, provenance and authentication can only take us so far. People who deliberately want to deceive others aren’t going to be particularly interested in following the rules.
The problem becomes even harder when convincing synthetic characters start building relationships with audiences over time. People already form emotional attachments to fictional characters, celebrities and online personalities they’ve never met. Give those characters the ability to interact directly with individuals, remember previous conversations and adjust their behaviour to suit the person they’re talking to, and the potential influence becomes considerably greater.
I don’t think we’ve begun to properly understand the consequences of that.
And it’s happening alongside another worrying development: the increasing concentration of power among the companies that control the technology, the data and the distribution networks.
I’ve been around financial markets and technology businesses long enough to know that commercial incentives matter. When an organisation has the ability to influence millions of people, and there’s a significant financial or political reward for doing so, expecting everyone involved to exercise restraint out of the goodness of their hearts seems rather optimistic.
I don’t want to see AI-generated creative work restricted simply because it makes people uncomfortable. The opportunities for individuals and small businesses are far too significant, and trying to stop the technology would probably be futile anyway.
But I do think we need to take the questions of control, transparency and accountability far more seriously than we currently are.
Whose Intention?
What I find particularly interesting about these two videos is how differently they affected me, despite being produced using broadly similar technology.
Jason Dainter has created a song I genuinely enjoy listening to. The fact that the singer doesn’t exist is interesting, but after a few listens it’s almost irrelevant. I enjoy the music, appreciate the production and recognise the creative talent behind it.
Telosapien has created something just as impressive technically, but the lyrics make you think about the implications of this technology in a rather different way. It’s clever, funny in places and deeply uncomfortable in others, particularly when you consider how easily similar techniques could be used for much less innocent purposes.
Both creators deserve enormous credit for what they’ve produced.
I suspect we’re going to see a lot more of this, and much of it will be extraordinary. The creative possibilities are enormous, especially for people who previously lacked the resources to produce work of this quality.
But I also suspect we’re heading into a period where our ability to manufacture convincing realities will improve much faster than our ability to work out what we should trust.
I’m perfectly happy listening to an AI-generated singer. I’ll probably listen to Jason’s song again later today.
I’m considerably less comfortable with the thought of synthetic personalities being used to tell millions of people what to think, particularly when we have no idea who is controlling them or what they’re trying to achieve.
The first song asks, “Is this not real?”
The second tells us, “It’s working as intended.”
I think the second one asks the more important question.
Both videos deserve to be watched in full. Full creative credit to Jason Dainter (@jasondainter) for Is This Not Real? and Telosapien (@telsopian) for Working as Intended. The performers may be artificial, but the creative talent behind these productions is very real.
Go take a and look
Scout - who just got funded
Newly funded startups, pre-seed to Series B, as the rounds happen.
Raise - who’s deploying
New funds with fresh capital and cheques to write.Wire - what changed, what matters
The intelligence feed that filters the noise, with the “so what” attached.
If you have not joined the Fusion42 Community on Telegram —
it is probably time to do so.
For the ❤️ of Startups
For the ❤️ of startups
✌🏼 & 💙
Derek
Thank you for reading. If you liked it, share it with your friends, colleagues and everyone interested in the startup Investor ecosystem.
If you've got suggestions, an article, research, your tech stack, or a job listing you want featured, just let me know! I'm keen to include it in the upcoming edition.
Please let me know what you think of it, love a feedback loop 🙏🏼
🛑 Get a different job.
Subscribe below and follow me on LinkedIn or Twitter to never miss an update.



